Written by John Walker, marketing consultant
In September, LeadingAge announced that Katie Smith Sloan, its president and CEO for the past decade, will step down at the end of March 2027. The board has already formed a search committee. If the national association for nonprofit and mission-driven aging services is planning a leadership transition, it is a safe bet that many of its member communities are too.
The numbers back that up. Challenger, Gray & Christmas, which tracks CEO departures across the country, reported that in September, government and nonprofit organizations had more CEO exits than any other sector. Hospital CEO exits through September were running 22 percent ahead of last year. Inside senior living, one executive recruiting firm reports that executive director roles are being replaced faster than at any point in the past twenty years, with median tenure for directors hired since 2022 under two years at many larger operators.
New leaders are not walking into calm water either. Ziegler’s 2026 workforce survey found average staff turnover of 35.4 percent at senior living and care organizations, with registered nurses turning over at nearly 41 percent. A new CEO or executive director inherits that churn on day one, along with occupancy targets, a budget where compensation eats up more than half of operating costs, and a board that wants to see progress.
When a new leader arrives, there is an unspoken expectation that change is coming. The board hired someone for a reason. Staff are waiting to see what will be different. Residents and families are watching too.
So new leaders often reach for the biggest lever available: a new strategic plan, a reorganization, a rebrand, a list of initiatives long enough to prove nothing is being left on the table. It feels like leadership. Most of the time, it is overload.
In a smaller, single-site community, the risk is higher. There is no large executive team to absorb thirty new priorities. The same few people who keep the dining room running and the census steady are the ones asked to carry every new idea. When everything is a priority, the work stalls between meetings, and the new leader’s credibility stalls with it.
Research on nonprofit transitions points to the same problem. A Bridgespan Group study of new nonprofit CEOs found that half never worked with their boards to clarify priorities, and two-thirds said they and their board had not set concrete measures and milestones for the first year. Without that clarity, a new leader is judged against expectations nobody wrote down. A separate study from NC State found that nonprofit boards do not become more functional during periods of turmoil. A new executive cannot count on the board to sort out priorities after the fact.
There is a better way to spend year one: pick three visible results, deliver them, and earn the trust to do more.
Three is not a magic number, but it is a disciplined one. It is enough to demonstrate momentum and small enough for a lean team to actually finish. Good first year wins tend to share four qualities.
They are visible. Residents, families, staff, and the board can see them without a slide deck. A stabilized nursing schedule. A memory care neighborhood that opens on time. A move-in pipeline that is finally moving.
They are tied to what the community is accountable for. Occupancy, financial health, a program launch, a construction milestone. Wins that connect to numbers the board already watches build credibility fastest.
They are owned by more than the leader. A win only the CEO can produce does not build the organization. A win delivered by a goal team, with a sponsor and a steady rhythm, shows staff that the new leader trusts them and leaves capability behind.
They are achievable with the people you have. Not the team you hope to hire next spring. The team on the payroll today.
Boards have a large hand in whether a transition works. PwC research on CEO succession found that successors to long serving leaders start with the odds stacked against them, and that visible board support is one of the deciding factors. That is worth remembering for any community replacing a leader who has been in place for ten or twenty years.
The most useful thing a board can do before a new leader arrives is answer one question together: what three results do we want our next leader to deliver in year one? Not a wish list. Three results, written down, agreed on, and revisited every quarter.
That conversation does several things at once. It forces the board to align before the search ends rather than after. It gives the new leader a clear mandate instead of a vague hope. And it gives everyone a fair way to measure progress, which protects the leader as much as the organization.
ForgeWorks was built from inside a mission-driven senior living organization, and we have watched leadership transitions up close. The pattern is consistent. The leaders who build lasting momentum are not the ones who change the most in year one. They are the ones who pick a few things, finish them, and let the results speak.
Our work with new leaders follows the same arc we use in every engagement. We diagnose the real conditions inside the organization: what is helping, what is in the way, and where strategy has gotten stuck between intent and execution. We design a short list of priorities that fit the community rather than a generic playbook. We help drive execution, setting up goal teams, sponsors, and a meeting rhythm that keeps work moving between board meetings. And we develop capability, so the next round of wins does not depend on us.
Good outside support stays in the background. The credit belongs to the new leader, who came in with a plan and delivered on it.
Whether your community has a new leader today, expects one in the coming year, or simply knows a transition will come someday, the question is the same.
What three results do we want our next leader to deliver in year one?
If your board cannot answer that in one meeting, that is useful information. It is also a good place to start.